It’s very important to understand from the get-go that the Fighting Antisemitism and Keeping Guns out of the Hands of Terrorists and Criminals Amendment Act 2026 (Qld) was passed under pressure from certain groups on the Queensland Government and the Premier, David Crisafulli, and his Attorney-General, despite pressure from various other groups for them not to pass that legislation.
That’s number one.
The second thing that is important to remember is that the legislation is not about civil liberties.
It’s not about civil liberties or individual freedom because it’s directed at the Palestinians and their organisation, that has put constant pressure on the governments for the past three years to rescind their support for the genocidal state of Israel.
So it’s not about antisemitism.
It’s not about civil liberties. It’s not even really about democratic rights. What it’s about is an assault on the pressure being exerted worldwide, but specifically here in Queensland, because it’s Queensland legislation, specifically directed at the Palestinians and their solidarity organisation, which here is represented by one group and one group only. And that is Justice for Palestine Magan-djin.
It’s important to understand this. It’s not other groups. It’s just that group. Why because that group is the only group pushing forward the Palestinian voice. The only group. And JFP is an umbrella organisation which includes a lot of other individuals, independents, Jewish people, solidarity and political groups.
Okay, they’re the first two points.
The performative nature of laws repressing Palestinian organisation
Now, the really important thing that I want to get across in this discussion is that the legislation passed by the Queensland Government is almost entirely, if not entirely, performative.
In other words, parliament has passed legislation to assuage the pressure coming from Zionist groups and military and weapons groups. Those interests want to prevent the Palestinian solidarity movement from growing so strong that it disrupts business as usual of assisting Israel in the slaughter of Palestinian people.
It’s very important to remember this. The law is entirely performative.
Why do I say that?
Well, there are a lot of reasons, and some of them are technical and others are political.
The constitutional and legal questions
Number one, the Zionist lobby put the word on the Queensland Government because, unlike other states, Queensland already had fairly strong protection against government repression of assembly and marches under the peaceful assembly act of 1992. Other states don’t possess that level of protection.
And then the other part about it is that, if you look at the way the legislation was put together and changed, even now the legislation is actually faulty.
It’s probably ultra vires the Commonwealth Constitution. And the Queensland Government and their lawyers would be aware of that technical failure in the law, that it’s in violation of, or ultra vires, the implied — that is, judge-made law — protection of political expression.
That affects everybody from the far right all the way across to solidarity groups.
If you look at section 52DA of the Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld), you see immediately that they put the legislation inside the Criminal Code of 1899.
So the government was making it look as if saying “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free” and/or “Globalise the intifada” is a crime.
But they neglected to do the fine drafting work of making this a ‘crime’ or a ‘misdemeanour’. The technical meanings have been incompetently misconstrued.
So a lot of things that follow from that legislation are at least, flaky. This doesn’t matter because the law is performative.
Like, for example, when you have an indictable offence that’s a crime or a misdemeanour, the police possess extra powers, like they can take DNA samples. They can’t do that here, and everyone should refuse to provide a DNA sample on request by police.
Anyway, the interplay of the Peaceful Assembly Act 1992 (Qld) and the Fighting Antisemitism and Keeping Guns out of the Hands of Terrorists and Criminals Amendment Act 2026 (Qld) — that’s there, and I’ve gone into that in detail before, so I won’t go there again.
But the performative nature of the legislation is that it’s a smokescreen. It’s throwing sand in the face of the Palestine solidarity movement hoping that we will overreact.
Selective police enforcement at the demonstration
And then, importantly, what the government will do, I’m almost positive now, because the Queensland Police Service have struggled to apply the legislation.
In fact, the ordinary police at the last demonstration clearly, clearly did not want to arrest all the people who were in violation of the prohibition on saying or displaying the prohibited expressions.
That’s clear. You look at the videos, look at the signs. A lot of people.
Take this example. Two mature women held up a large sign bearing the words “From the river to the sea” from the get-go. It was a big sign, and they led the march with it right through the city.
Then they came all the way back to Emma Miller Place, and only then did police take the sign and escort the women into a van. This was certainly a performance by the policewoman in charge.
Now, why didn’t the police want to arrest all the people breaking the law?
Because police know the government wants it to be performative.
And so all police were doing was making a performance of support for the legislated prohibition on saying those expressions.
And they know it’s directed at the organisers. So they pick out people. So they’re selective in how they do it.
Ordinary police held back from arresting people on the 15th of November 2026 in Emma Miller Place. Why would the cops go and arrest someone in a music group? Why would they go and arrest someone who has COVID? So they didn’t. Why would you go and arrest someone who’s not in a strong organised group?
Police wouldn’t do it. What’s the point?
The next move: restrictions on public assemblies
The other thing is, the police know and want — it is clear they want, and the government wants — to change the Peaceful Assembly Act 1992 (Qld) so there’s a compulsion, certainly the Brisbane City Council wants this, there’s a compulsion on anyone applying for or notifying — at the moment it’s a notification system — notifying that an assembly or a march is going to occur, that those people in the future will be compelled by legislation or some tweaking of the existing legislation to actually apply for a permit to march or to assemble or to do or say certain things. This intern will be selectively refused as occurred in the late 1970s during the street march ban.
So they’re going to impose stricter controls on the rights of the solidarity organisation to conduct activities, especially in the city, outside weapons manufacturers, outside the Boeing building, anywhere where people are uncomfortable with the Australian governments, plural, support for the murdering of Palestinian people, and particularly children.
Now, how are they going to go about this?
Well, that’s an interesting question.
Presently, you can’t actually have an assembly or a march in Queen Street Mall.
But they’ve already introduced legislation that you can’t have a — there are prohibitive fines against people, as we’ve learned, who conduct an assembly or a march inside the Queen Street Mall which interferes with business.
They’ve got a lot of support from business to do that.
But they’ve also made the prohibition on assembly and marches all the way down Albert Street and right down near the Boeing building and right down to the new railway station.
That’s the Cross River Rail — they’ve protected that already so that it’s very difficult for organised groups, not just small groups but organised groups, to carry on a successful mass assembly in the vicinity of 123 Albert Street, the railway station, all the way up to the mall and King George Square
So I’m pretty well convinced now that that’s the next move by the government to attack democratic rights.
The political objective of Palestine solidarity
And a third point I want to make very clear.
It’s not the job of Palestine solidarity groups here or elsewhere to take on battles which relate to other political objectives. Our aims are entirely Palestinian. To defeat the protagonists of the genocide.
Yes, our political objective is unique, to prevent the government from arming the genocide, and prevent the government from carrying on any activity, any activities, to provide weapons for the genocide, to stop the political cover being provided by all governments in Australia to murder Palestinians. That’s the real crime.
Ian Curr
17 November 2026
I just got an email from Getup inviting recipients to flood the NSW parliament with appointments to protest the overriding legislation to enable a coal mine after it had been declared illegal in the High Court. They made the point the an email can be deleted unread, but the pollies have to deal with an entry in their calendar. Maybe an appropriate tactic here.